Do Credit Cards Make You Gain Weight? What is Correlation, and How to Distinguish It from Causation
Do Credit Cards Make You Gain Weight? What is Correlation, and How to Distinguish It from CausationEnglish
Department of Economics
This lesson introduces the students to the concepts of correlation and causation, and the difference between the two. The main learning objective is to encourage students to think critically about various possible explanations for a correlation, and to evaluate their plausibility, rather than passively taking presented information on faith. To give students the right tools for such analysis, the lesson covers most common reasons behind a correlation, and different possible types of causation.
During activities, students will practice on real-life examples of correlations, and anecdotal evidence from their own lives to distinguish cases with no causation behind a correlation through cases when examining a correlation can lead to useful insights. One of the interactive activities requires a blackboard or a whiteboard. Alternatively, a large, poster-size piece of paper on an easel or taped to a wall can be used.
There are no prerequisites for this lesson. It is suitable for all high school students, and should particularly benefit older students. The lesson should take about one hour to complete. The recorded video is 27 minutes. There are six activities. Activity 2 requires the most time, of about 10-15 minutes. The rest of the activities are fairly quick and require around 4 minutes each. After the actual video lesson, there is a video Teacher Guide to assist in conducting the lesson.
Kamilya Tazhibayeva is a postdoctoral researcher at the Department of Economics at MIT. Kamilya has a PhD in economics from the University of Chicago, and a BA in economics and mathematics from Macalester College, MN. Her main field of research is development economics, with focuses on human capital accumulation and agricultural transformation. Kamilya’s current work is on modeling a proper metric for measuring how variations in weather, and by extension climate change, affect rainfed crops, and using this metric to design affordable weather insurance products for farmers who grow rainfed crops.
Additional Online Resources
Khan Academy: Correlation and Causality
This resource is a Khan Academy video explaining why correlation does not imply causality.
Duke University: Using Statistics to Determine Causal Relationships (PDF)
From Duke University, this is an excellent overview of how to use statistics to determine causal relationships.
Date-driven Intelligence: If correlation doesn’t imply causation, then what does?
Provided by Data Driven Intelligence, this site answers the question: If correlation doesn’t imply causation, then what does?
Sense and Science USA: Causation vs Correlation
Sponsored by Sense about Science (SAS), this resource provides a short and excellent explanation of causation versus correlation.
YouTube: How Ice Cream Kills! Correlation vs. Causation
This resource is a short, fun YouTube video on causation and correlation.